- Business in Poland -
Pre-trial detention – when a court may impose it and how to defend yourself
Pre-trial detention is the most severe preventive measure available in criminal proceedings. It consists of depriving a suspect or defendant of their liberty for a period determined by the court [1]. In practice, this means procedural isolation imposed before any judgment is delivered. For that reason, its use is subject to strict statutory conditions, and the court should assess whether the purpose of the proceedings can be achieved by using less restrictive measures.
In criminal cases, especially those involving white-collar crime, a decision to impose detention affects not only the procedural position of the suspect, but also the company’s operations, crisis management, relations with business partners, and reputation. That is why risk assessment and a swift procedural response are crucial. A broader overview of procedural protection is also discussed in the criminal law section.
Pre-trial detention - statutory grounds
The legal basis for preventive measures, including pre-trial detention, is Article 249 of the Polish Code of Criminal Procedure. Under this provision, there must be a high likelihood that the suspect committed the alleged offence [1]. Mere suspicion is not enough. The evidence must be strong enough to justify interference with an individual’s liberty.
In addition, the court examines the so-called specific grounds under Article 258 of the Code of Criminal Procedure [1]. These most commonly include:
- a risk of absconding or hiding, especially where the person’s identity cannot be established or the suspect has no permanent residence in the country,
- a justified risk of obstructing the proceedings, meaning unlawful interference with the case, influencing witnesses or co-suspects, or destroying evidence,
- the prospect of a severe penalty, if the accused has been charged with a felony or an offence punishable by imprisonment with a maximum sentence of at least 8 years, or where the court of first instance has sentenced them to imprisonment for no less than 3 years,
- exceptionally - the need to prevent the accused from committing a new serious offence against life, health, or public safety, especially where they have threatened to commit such an offence.
These are the key elements covered by the concept of grounds for pre-trial detention. In practice, the court should identify specific factual circumstances rather than rely on generic formulaic statements. In business crime cases, it is particularly important to determine whether the alleged risk of obstruction arises from the suspect’s actual conduct or merely from the nature of the case and access to documentation.
When a court should not impose detention
The Polish Code of Criminal Procedure also provides for the so-called negative grounds for pre-trial detention. Under Articles 257 and 259, detention should not be imposed if another preventive measure is sufficient, or if deprivation of liberty would cause exceptionally severe consequences for the suspect or their immediate family [1]. The person’s health, family situation, and the nature of their professional duties may also be relevant.
In practice, the defence will often argue that the aims of the proceedings can be secured by non-custodial measures such as:
- bail,
- police supervision,
- a ban on contacting specific individuals,
- a travel ban combined with the surrender of a passport,
- suspension from official duties or a ban on conducting specific business activities.
How long pre-trial detention lasts
The question of how long pre-trial detention lasts arises very often, because this measure may be extended. As a rule, during the preparatory proceedings, pre-trial detention may be imposed for a period not exceeding 3 months [1]. If, due to special circumstances of the case, the preparatory proceedings could not be completed, the court having jurisdiction over the case may extend the detention for a further specified period, which in total may not exceed 12 months [1].
As a rule, the total period of detention until the first judgment by the court of first instance should not exceed 2 years. Any further extension is possible only in exceptional cases and requires compliance with the additional conditions set out in Article 263 of the Code of Criminal Procedure [1].
That does not, however, mean the process is automatic. Each extension must be justified separately. The European Court of Human Rights has repeatedly stressed that prolonged detention requires specific and current reasons, not a repetition of earlier arguments [3].
How to defend yourself against pre-trial detention
An effective defence begins even before the detention hearing. Speed of action, analysis of the evidence, and preparation of arguments against custodial isolation all matter. In practice, the key steps are:
- challenging the alleged high likelihood that the offence was committed, where the evidence is incomplete, internally inconsistent, or based mainly on assumptions,
- showing that there is no real risk of absconding or obstructing the proceedings,
- demonstrating stable professional, family, and financial ties,
- proposing non-custodial preventive measures,
- relying on circumstances under Article 259 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, including health issues or exceptionally severe consequences for the family and business.
In managerial and business cases, it is particularly important to organise documents and quickly secure material that may rebut allegations of obstructing the proceedings. Evidence showing the company’s transparency and implemented compliance procedures may also prove helpful.
Pre-trial detention - appeal and further remedies
If the court imposes detention, it is possible to file an appeal. This is the primary legal remedy, which is why the phrase appeal against pre-trial detention in practice refers mainly to an interlocutory appeal against the court’s detention order [1]. The appeal should focus on errors in the factual findings, the absence of real specific grounds, and the failure to consider non-custodial measures.
Regardless of the appeal, the defence may also apply to have the preventive measure revoked or changed if new circumstances arise or the grounds for continued isolation become weaker. In the longer term, it is also important to monitor deadlines and the quality of the reasoning given in subsequent decisions extending detention.
The significance of detention in business and reputational cases
For a management board member, company owner, or director, pre-trial detention has consequences that go beyond the criminal case itself. It creates a risk of operational disruption, loss of access to key data, interruption in decision-making continuity, and often a communication crisis as well. In such matters, the legal defence strategy should be coordinated with corporate actions, HR, and communication with stakeholders.
This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. If a specific situation requires an urgent assessment of procedural and business risks, support is available by contacting the KKZ team via the Kopeć & Zaborowski law firm website.
FAQ - pre-trial detention
1. Can a prosecutor impose pre-trial detention?
No. A prosecutor may file an application, but the decision is made exclusively by the court [1].
2. Is being charged with a serious offence alone enough for detention?
Not always. In addition to a high likelihood that the offence was committed, there must be specific grounds, such as a risk of obstructing the proceedings or absconding [1].
3. How long does pre-trial detention last under the court’s initial decision?
As a rule, up to 3 months during the preparatory proceedings. Any further extension requires a separate court order and justification [1].
4. Can detention be avoided by offering bail?
Yes, but it depends on the court’s assessment. Bail is one of the non-custodial preventive measures and may be sufficient if it secures the proper course of the proceedings [1].
5. What does an appeal against pre-trial detention look like?
In practice, it involves filing an interlocutory appeal against the order imposing detention. It is also possible to later seek revocation or modification of the measure if the circumstances of the case change [1].
6. Does health matter when the court decides on detention?
Yes. The court should take into account the person’s health and whether detention would cause exceptionally severe consequences for the suspect or their immediate family [1].
Bibliography
[1] Act of 6 June 1997 - Code of Criminal Procedure, consolidated text: Journal of Laws of 2024, item 37, as amended.
[2] Constitution of the Republic of Poland of 2 April 1997, Journal of Laws of 1997 No. 78, item 483, as amended.
[3] Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, signed in Rome on 4 November 1950, Journal of Laws of 1993 No. 61, item 284, as amended.
Author: adw. Maciej Zaborowski, Managing Partner
E-mail: m.zaborowski@kkz.com.pl






