- Business in Poland -
Criminal Appeal – Deadlines, Structure and Most Common Mistakes
A criminal appeal is a legal remedy against a first-instance court judgment, aimed at reviewing whether the decision is correct in terms of both facts and law. In practice, a criminal appeal is not simply about expressing dissatisfaction with a judgment. It must identify specific grounds of appeal, procedural or substantive errors, and the outcome sought. In criminal proceedings, especially those involving managers, business owners and white-collar matters, an improperly drafted appeal may result in losing a real chance of having the judgment changed.
Appeal against a criminal conviction - what determines effectiveness
The effectiveness of an appeal depends primarily on three elements: meeting the deadline, properly formulating the grounds of appeal, and providing sound reasoning. A mere belief that the judgment is unfair is not enough. The appellate court reviews the case within the limits of the appeal, and only more broadly in situations provided for by statute [1].
In cases with significant reputational or business implications, precision becomes particularly important. This is especially true where the judgment may affect the ability to serve on company boards, relationships with contractors, regulatory proceedings, or the assessment of due diligence on the part of the management team.
More information about appellate practice and issues related to appeals against criminal judgments can be found in the criminal law materials prepared by KKZ.
Criminal appeal deadline - the most important procedural time limits
The phrase criminal appeal deadline usually comes up when, after a judgment is announced, a procedural decision must be made quickly. There are two key stages.
- Request for written grounds of the judgment and service of those grounds - as a rule, this must be filed within 7 days from the date the judgment is announced [1].
- Appeal against a criminal judgment - this must be filed within 14 days from service of the judgment together with the written grounds [1].
If a party fails to request the written grounds within the statutory time limit, the right to file an appeal will, as a rule, expire. In certain cases, extraordinary procedural mechanisms may still be available, but they do not replace an ordinary appeal.
In some situations, reinstatement of the deadline is possible, but this requires showing that the missed deadline occurred through no fault of the party [1]. This is an exception, not a standard solution.
What a criminal appeal should look like
A well-prepared criminal appeal has a clear structure. The document should not only be formally correct, but also strategically well thought out. It will usually include:
- identification of the judgment being appealed,
- an indication of whether the judgment is being challenged in full or in part,
- grounds of appeal,
- reasoning in support of those grounds,
- appellate motions, for example a request to amend or set aside the judgment,
- a signature and the required attachments.
The grounds of appeal are the most important part. They determine the scope and direction of the appellate review. Depending on the case, they may concern, among other things:
- breach of procedural provisions, if the error could have affected the content of the judgment,
- an error in the findings of fact forming the basis of the ruling,
- misapplication or breach of substantive law,
- a manifestly disproportionate penalty [1].
In business crime cases, common grounds often concern the assessment of documents, expert opinions, the liability of management board members, and the interpretation of the relationship between business risk and criminal liability.
Mistakes in a criminal appeal - what most often weakens an appeal
Mistakes in a criminal appeal usually do not arise from a single failing, but from a combination of haste, overly general arguments, and poor selection of grounds. In practice, the following problems occur most often:
- Overly general grounds
Stating that the court "incorrectly assessed the evidence" or "wrongly convicted the defendant" is not sufficient. It is necessary to specify which evidence, which evaluation rules, and exactly how they were breached. - Mixing factual and legal grounds
A challenge based on an error in factual findings must be constructed differently from a challenge based on a breach of substantive law. Mixing them weakens the consistency of the appeal. - No link between the error and the content of the judgment
Not every procedural violation has appellate relevance. It must be shown that it could have affected the ruling. - Too many grounds of appeal
Building an appeal around a dozen weak arguments often obscures the strongest ones. - Incorrect final request
A request to amend or set aside the judgment should follow from the grounds presented. The lack of this logical connection can be a serious defect.
In criminal cases with reputational significance, another common mistake is focusing solely on image or PR-based narratives, without sufficiently grounding the arguments in legal provisions and the evidence. The appellate court does not assess crisis communication - it assesses whether the judgment is correct.
Appeal against a criminal judgment in business and management cases
In cases involving white-collar crime, an appeal against a criminal judgment requires particular caution. The case file is usually extensive, and the evidence often includes accounting records, corporate correspondence, compliance procedures, economic analyses and specialist opinions. These cases rarely allow for an effective appeal based solely on one general allegation.
The impact of the judgment on the business is also important. A conviction, or even the upholding of adverse findings, may affect banking relationships, tenders, decisions made by business partners, and sometimes even civil and employment liability. For this reason, the analysis of an appeal should cover not only the judgment itself, but also its further legal and organisational consequences.
What to remember before filing a criminal appeal
Before preparing an appeal, it is worth checking several issues:
- whether the deadline for filing the request for written grounds has been met,
- whether the judgment is being challenged in full or only to a specific extent,
- which errors genuinely have appellate significance,
- whether the arguments are based on the case file and the relevant legal provisions,
- what outcome is realistically achievable at the appellate stage.
This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. If you need an assessment of whether a specific criminal appeal has real merit, and how to limit procedural and reputational risks, it is worth asking specialists to review the case using the contact details available on the Kopeć & Zaborowski law firm website.
FAQ - criminal appeal
1. What is the deadline for filing a criminal appeal?
As a rule, you must first file a request for the written grounds of the judgment and service of those grounds within 7 days of the judgment being announced, and then file the appeal within 14 days of service of the judgment with the written grounds [1].
2. Can a criminal appeal be filed without the written grounds of the judgment?
As a rule, no. To file an appeal against a first-instance judgment, you must first effectively file a request for the preparation and service of the written grounds. Failure to submit such a request on time generally closes the door to an ordinary appeal [1].
3. What are the most common mistakes in a criminal appeal?
The most common are overly general grounds, failure to link the error to the content of the judgment, mixing factual and legal grounds, and formulating too many weak arguments instead of focusing on a few key ones.
4. Does the appellate court always hold a hearing?
No, not in every case. An appeal may be examined at a hearing or in closed session, in the circumstances provided for by the Code of Criminal Procedure [1].
5. Can the severity of the penalty be challenged in an appeal?
Yes. One of the possible grounds of appeal is a manifestly disproportionate penalty, if the penalty imposed by the first-instance court is clearly inadequate in light of the circumstances of the case [1].
6. Is reinstatement of the deadline for filing an appeal possible?
Yes, but only exceptionally. It must be shown as plausible that the deadline was missed through no fault of the party, and the request must be filed in compliance with the applicable procedural requirements [1].
Bibliography
[1] Act of 6 June 1997 - Code of Criminal Procedure, consolidated text: Journal of Laws 2024, item 37, as amended.
[2] Act of 6 June 1997 - Criminal Code, consolidated text: Journal of Laws 2025, item 383, as amended.
[3] Supreme Court official website, case law and information on criminal proceedings, https://www.sn.pl.
Author: adw. Maciej Zaborowski, Managing Partner
E-mail: m.zaborowski@kkz.com.pl






